The Problem With Choice

By David Kidd, BPR

For decades, marketers assumed that consumers wanted more choice.

More brands. More products. More television channels. More music. More ways to buy, watch and listen.

They were right.

But perhaps we have now reached the point where more choice isn’t necessarily making life better.

Psychologist Barry Schwartz gave the phenomenon a name in his 2004 book “The Paradox of Choice: Why More Is Less”. His argument: past a certain point, more options don’t liberate people, they paralyse them. More choice means more chance to regret whatever you didn’t pick, higher expectations that are harder to meet, and more grounds to blame yourself if the choice turns out badly.

The theory was backed by evidence a few years earlier. In one of the best-known experiments on consumer choice, psychologists Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper offered shoppers either 24 varieties of jam or just six. The larger display attracted more attention. But consumers presented with the smaller selection were considerably more likely to actually buy something. Their research challenged the seemingly obvious assumption that more choice always produces better consumer outcomes. The study appeared in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology under the title “When Choice Is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?” It’s what became known as “choice overload”.

And in 2026, we’re surrounded by it.

Want to listen to some music? Virtually every song ever recorded is sitting in your smart phone.

Want something to watch tonight? Good luck.

Think about how dramatically the consumer world has changed in just 20 years. In 2006, television was largely about choosing between a relatively small number of scheduled channels. Radio meant choosing between the stations available in your market. Music collections consisted of CDs, downloads and whatever happened to be on your iPod. YouTube was barely a year old. Spotify hadn’t even launched.

In 2006, the media industry’s strength was largely “scarcity”.

In 2026, the problem is “abundance”.

Consumers can choose from broadcast radio and television, streaming services, YouTube, TikTok, podcasts, catch-up television, social media, millions of songs and an almost infinite supply of creators.

The interesting thing is that consumers aren’t necessarily finding this liberating. Nielsen’s 2025 State of Play research found 45% of streaming consumers describe the streaming experience as overwhelming. Viewers globally spend an average of 14 minutes simply trying to find something to watch. Almost one in five eventually abandon the viewing session altogether. Imagine telling a television executive in 2006 that one of television’s problems in 2026 would be that viewers have so much television available that they can’t decide what to watch.

The Paradox for Radio. Radio faces exactly the same problem.

As I have mentioned in a previous article, in 2006, your principal competitors were the other stations on the dial. In 2026, the listener can choose radio, Spotify, podcasts, YouTube, audiobooks, personalised playlists or thousands of radio stations from around the world. Podcast consumption alone demonstrates how dramatically the competitive set has expanded. Edison Research estimates Americans now spend around 773 million hours a week with podcasts….355% more than in 2015.

Yet there is something interesting buried inside all this choice. Radio remains remarkably resilient.

Edison data for 2025 showed AM/FM still accounted for around 34% of total daily audio time in America, ahead of streaming music, YouTube and podcasts.

Why?

Perhaps one of radio’s supposed weaknesses has become one of its strengths.

Radio removes the need to choose.

Industry researchers have a name for this too: “lean-back” versus “lean-in” listening.

Lean-back covers radio and anything else that starts playing the moment you press one button.

Lean-in covers the services that ask you to search, build playlists and manage a library….there’s  more work involved.

Turn your favourite radio station on. Someone has chosen the music. Someone has found the stories. Someone tells you what’s happening. Someone hopefully makes you laugh.

You don’t have to search through 100 million songs deciding which one you want to hear next. That’s what a great programmer does for you.

The opportunity for both television and radio may therefore be less about offering consumers even more content and more about becoming trusted curators of content.

That changes the job of the radio programmer and television programmer. Twenty years ago, they controlled access to content. Today, consumers can access almost anything without them.  The value of the programmer in 2026 is helping audiences navigate everything that’s available.

The great media battle of 2026 isn’t simply about more content.

It’s about making great content and making the choice easy.

Discussion

No comments on this post yet, start a discussion below!

Join the discussion